{
  "schema": "https://ixo.world/research/claim-ledger/v1",
  "paper": "Intelligent Voluntary Cooperation",
  "version": "0.9.0-draft",
  "generatedFrom": "data/claim-ledger.csv",
  "claimCount": 15,
  "claims": [
    {
      "claimId": "C01",
      "claimText": "Coordination becomes a limiting problem as intelligent agency becomes cheaper and more abundant.",
      "classes": [
        "I",
        "H"
      ],
      "confidence": "preliminary",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part I",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "Suchman2006",
        "SchmidtSimone1996",
        "NIST2023"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "A framing inference; the paper does not assert a measured economy-wide threshold.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "No meaningful increase in coordination cost, failure, or governance burden as agentic action grows.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The motivating problem is overstated.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C02",
      "claimText": "Central orchestration has structural limits and remains superior in tightly coupled, known-sequence, timing-critical, or single-accountability tasks.",
      "classes": [
        "E",
        "I"
      ],
      "confidence": "moderate",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Parts I and IV",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "Suchman2006",
        "BeckersEtAl1994",
        "SwarmWorld2026"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Comparative, not universal: mode advantage depends on task and risk.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Orchestration dominates across exploratory, adaptive, and turnover-heavy tasks without material cost.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The hybrid coordination thesis narrows.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C03",
      "claimText": "Persistent traces in a shared environment can mediate useful indirect coordination.",
      "classes": [
        "E"
      ],
      "confidence": "high",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part II",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "Grasse1959",
        "BeckersEtAl1994",
        "Hutchins1995",
        "SchmidtSimone1996"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Established across bounded domains; not proof of universal scalability or voluntariness.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Effects fail to transfer beyond narrow insect or toy settings.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The proposed mechanism loses its cross-domain basis.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C04",
      "claimText": "In SwarmWorld, persistent shared state and executable artifacts supported differentiated behavior, broad reuse, technological lineages, and portfolio-level advantages under the reported conditions.",
      "classes": [
        "X"
      ],
      "confidence": "moderate",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part III",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "SwarmWorld2026"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "One model/configuration; four seeds per condition; post-hoc roles; simulated world; 95% concerns first reuse; 288-tick persistence test.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Independent reproduction fails or reported advantages disappear under matched controls.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "SwarmWorld cannot serve as the agent-system catalyst.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C05",
      "claimText": "Persistent artifacts are a distinct and useful unit of analysis in collective intelligence.",
      "classes": [
        "I"
      ],
      "confidence": "moderate",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Parts II and III",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "Hutchins1995",
        "SchmidtSimone1996",
        "DerexBoyd2016",
        "Voyager2023",
        "SwarmWorld2026"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Synthesis across fields, not a settled standalone theory.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Artifact-centered models add no explanatory or predictive value beyond messaging or shared memory.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The architecture should be reframed around another unit.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C06",
      "claimText": "Voluntary cooperation requires legible identity, informed choice, practical capability, bounded authority, fair incentives, contestability, and meaningful refusal or exit.",
      "classes": [
        "I",
        "N"
      ],
      "confidence": "moderate",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part IV",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "Ostrom1990",
        "Ostrom2010",
        "research-gap-dossier"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "A normative-institutional synthesis; requirements vary with dependency, law, and prior obligations.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "The conditions fail to predict voluntariness or systematically exclude legitimate cooperative forms.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The term voluntary must be narrowed or abandoned.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C07",
      "claimText": "Actor-specific affordances may help participants discover useful contributions without central assignment.",
      "classes": [
        "I",
        "H"
      ],
      "confidence": "preliminary",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part IV",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "Gibson1979"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Digital capability-aware affordances are an architectural extension of ecological affordances.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Matched trials show no useful-contribution gain or reveal hidden assignment as the real mechanism.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "Affordance discovery should not be a design priority.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C08",
      "claimText": "A bounded cooperative environment needs intent, participants, legible state, legitimate actions, persistence, evaluation, consequence, governance, and exit.",
      "classes": [
        "I",
        "H"
      ],
      "confidence": "preliminary",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part IV",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "Ostrom1990",
        "SchmidtSimone1996",
        "NIST2023"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Proposed minimum primitive set; subject to formalization and ablation.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Equivalent outcomes are achieved reliably with a materially smaller or different primitive set.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The computational model must be revised.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C09",
      "claimText": "Persistence increases both coordination power and governance risk.",
      "classes": [
        "E",
        "I"
      ],
      "confidence": "high",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part V",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "RFC9162",
        "NIST2023",
        "research-gap-dossier"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Risks depend on discoverability, write authority, correction, expiry, and consequence.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Persistent shared state shows no additional poisoning, lock-in, privacy, or capture risk versus ephemeral systems.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The governance burden is overstated.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C10",
      "claimText": "Separating claims, evidence, evaluation, decision, authority, and authoritative read-back can separate cognition from consequence.",
      "classes": [
        "I",
        "S"
      ],
      "confidence": "moderate",
      "status": "verified",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part VI",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "W3CVC2025",
        "PROVDM2013",
        "IXOBlockchainV8Claims",
        "EvaluationsEngine",
        "IXOVerify"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Components are implemented at different maturity levels; no claim of one fully conformed end-to-end production path.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "A consequential boundary is bypassable, circular, non-independent, or provides no error reduction.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The reality-boundary architecture is unsound.",
      "ownerSignoff": "pending-technical-owner"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C11",
      "claimText": "A Qi Topic is specified as a durable bounded context for intent, state, authority, collaboration, and outcome, and can be interpreted as a candidate cooperative environment.",
      "classes": [
        "S",
        "I",
        "H"
      ],
      "confidence": "moderate",
      "status": "verified",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part VII",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "TopicProtocolRC1"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Topic Protocol is a draft implementation candidate; live discovery, E2EE agent, replay, and action gates remain open.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Conformance or user studies show Topics remain passive containers or worsen coordination.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "Qi correspondence is downgraded or removed.",
      "ownerSignoff": "pending-topic-owner"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C12",
      "claimText": "Portal Flows and Qi runtime packages provide implemented collaborative and executable-artifact primitives that may support inheritance, but cumulative improvement has not been demonstrated.",
      "classes": [
        "S",
        "I",
        "H"
      ],
      "confidence": "moderate",
      "status": "verified",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part VII",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "PortalDevelop",
        "QiRuntimesMain"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Implementation evidence supports primitives, not emergent culture, broad deployment, or compounding performance.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Artifacts prove non-portable, non-composable, unsafe to reuse, or show no longitudinal performance gain.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "Executable-inheritance claims are removed.",
      "ownerSignoff": "pending-portal-runtime-owners"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C13",
      "claimText": "Different classes of cooperative state require different integrity, confidentiality, authority, and consensus mechanisms.",
      "classes": [
        "I",
        "N"
      ],
      "confidence": "moderate",
      "status": "sourced",
      "manuscriptSection": "Parts V and VIII",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "W3CDID2022",
        "W3CVC2025",
        "PROVDM2013",
        "RFC9162",
        "TopicProtocolRC1"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Architectural principle; exact placement is context- and threat-dependent.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "One mechanism consistently dominates without material confidentiality, cost, latency, or governance trade-offs.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The layered state model should be simplified.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C14",
      "claimText": "Evaluated contribution histories may improve later decisions, reputation, and cooperation.",
      "classes": [
        "H"
      ],
      "confidence": "speculative",
      "status": "proposed",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part IX",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "experimental-protocol"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "No current Qi outcome claim; privacy, bias, strategic gaming, and lock-in are live risks.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Longitudinal data show no predictive lift or show harms exceeding benefits.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "History-based decision features should be limited or rejected.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    },
    {
      "claimId": "C15",
      "claimText": "Accumulated, governed cooperative state may create compounding utility and defensibility.",
      "classes": [
        "H"
      ],
      "confidence": "speculative",
      "status": "proposed",
      "manuscriptSection": "Part IX",
      "supportingEvidence": [
        "experimental-protocol"
      ],
      "scopeOrLimitation": "Strategic hypothesis only; portability and public standards may reduce switching costs while pollution may reverse gains.",
      "falsifierOrRetirementCondition": "Mature environments offer no cohort advantage, utility is non-compounding, or governance cost dominates.",
      "consequenceIfWrong": "The network-effect and defensibility thesis is rejected.",
      "ownerSignoff": "editorial"
    }
  ]
}
